Close Menu
Fund Focus News
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • Mutual Funds KYC: How To Check And Update Your Status, Here’s A Step-by-Step Guide | Savings and Investments News
    • SBI Mutual Fund’s top 5 SIP plans – up to 20% CAGR in 10 years; Rs 10K investment turns into Rs 35 lakh – Money News
    • SoftBank Seeks Billions in Overseas Bonds to Accelerate AI Expansion
    • Indonesia plans debut yuan bonds as dim sum issuance hits record
    • Sovereign wealth funds, including Singapore’s GIC, drive biggest deals in US$3.5 trillion M&A year
    • Buffalo Comptroller appealing judge’s ruling over her refusal to issue bonds
    • 3 Unstoppable Growth ETFs That Could Turn $10,000 Into More Than $12 million With Practically Zero Effort
    • The Housing Market Is Slowing Down But These REIT ETFs Are Running Hot. Thank AI.
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Fund Focus News
    • Home
    • Bonds
    • ETFs
    • Funds
    • Investments
    • Mutual Funds
    • Property Investments
    • SIP
    Fund Focus News
    Home»Bonds»Green bonds versus SLBs: Which structure is making the most impact?
    Bonds

    Green bonds versus SLBs: Which structure is making the most impact?

    October 29, 2024


    With the green and sustainability-linked bond market expanding, investors are increasingly assessing the potential of their fixed-income holdings to drive climate impact. But which bond structure best supports net zero ambitions?

    The combined issuance of green, social, and sustainability-linked bonds has now exceeded $5trn, according to the Climate Bonds Initative. Yet, the lack of an internationally recognised standard has sparked criticism, with some arguing that these bonds have become vehicles for greenwashing. The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) is set to address this with new guidance on sustainability-related terminology in fund names.

    The new rules, which will come into effect in December 2024, will require fund managers to align their portfolios with either the Paris-Aligned or Climate Transition Benchmarks. This change could prompt a significant overhaul of funds branded as “sustainable.”

    Speaking at Net Zero Investor’s Annual Conference, Véronique Chapplow, an investment specialist at T. Rowe Price—a major provider of green bonds—acknowledged the increasing scrutiny of labelled bonds.

    “I think companies that issue these types of instruments really realise they need to put in the work to ensure credibility… there’s auditing, reporting, and expertise required, and that’s beneficial for the industry. We’ve designed our proprietary ESG-level bonds to rigorously screen the yield process, reporting, and validity after issuance. Due diligence is still necessary, but the market is more mature than it was a few years ago,” she emphasised.

    Enter SLBs

    But some argue that labelled debt may not be the most impactful vehicle for addressing climate change. For example, the Anthropocene Fixed Income Institute (AFII) has been a strong proponent of sustainability-linked bonds (SLBs) and recently published an extensive guide on their benefits.

    At the conference, Josephine Richardson, former credit trader at JP Morgan Chase and now head of research at AFII, explained her perspective on SLBs:

    “Use-of-proceeds bonds like green bonds say, ‘I’ll take your money and spend it on specific, eligible projects,’ giving a layer of investor comfort. In contrast, sustainability-linked bonds don’t restrict spending to certain projects but instead commit to specific KPIs; if they’re missed or met, it adjusts bond terms, usually through a coupon adjustment. This structure offers greater accountability, though not necessarily a direct tie to asset use.”

    Richardson stressed the enhanced accountability mechanisms that SLBs offer: “Green bonds have been effective from a PR standpoint, especially for portfolios needing regulatory compliance and transparency. But they’re still just bonds; investors can’t claim ownership over those ‘green assets’ if the issuer defaults. On the other hand, sustainability-linked bonds can provide tangible accountability through KPIs—if the issuer fails to meet targets, it impacts their capital costs. This accountability could be impactful in terms of supporting behaviour change.”

    The role of green bonds

    In contrast, Chandra Gopinathan, chair of the bondholder stewardship group at the Institutional Investor Group on Climate Change, argued that green bonds remain valuable in decarbonisation strategies, particularly for high-emitting sectors.

    “In high-emitting sectors, green bonds are crucial as they allocate capital directly towards green commitments,” he stated, adding that investors should consider the issuer’s overall climate stance rather than viewing the green bond in isolation. “We need to consider the full financing strategy, not just a single product or bond. This holistic view is even more vital as corporates are now moving towards mandated transition planning, so alignment with broader financing strategies becomes key to meaningful transition,” he emphasised.

    Transparency is central to achieving this, Gopinathan argued:

    “When we discuss accountability mechanisms, it’s not just about disclosure but enabling investors to make informed decisions on what the issuer is achieving. The quality of the issuer’s commitment, alignment, and transparency are crucial in evaluating both green and sustainability-linked bonds.”

    Chapplow highlighted that a broader approach could also be impactful:

    “One of our impact strategies, our global impact credits, actually has about 40% of its allocation in non-labelled bonds. We don’t restrict ourselves to just green or labelled bonds but seek companies that actively contribute to big problems we’re addressing. Greenwashing is a significant risk, so rigorous scrutiny of these bonds, and especially issuer credibility, is essential.”

    Powerful levers

    With the debate heating up, panellists shared examples of how investors could apply pressure on issuers across different structures. Richardson cited the example of London & Quadrant Housing Trust, which recently missed an emissions reduction target for its SLB, incurring a $400 million penalty—a result she argued was positive for investors.

    “Investors want accountability in bonds tied to performance metrics, not just compliance labels. While green bonds provide brand recognition and regulatory ease, sustainability-linked bonds hold issuers accountable through performance metrics. That’s appealing for investors who want the company to bear responsibility if targets are missed.”

    Gopinathan added that accountability mechanisms could also be integrated into labelled debt:

    “Investors should avoid over-reliance on labels and ensure they understand the issuer holistically. The Avengoa case is a prime example: the green label misled investors who overlooked fundamental governance issues. Sustainability labels alone are insufficient without thorough vetting of the issuer.”

    The bigger picture

    Ultimately, the panellists agreed that a comprehensive view of an issuer’s transition strategy and greater transparency are essential to address greenwashing in fixed income. Gopinathan concluded:

    “Investors are often taking risks in these evolving bond structures, even without perfect information. It’s crucial to assess both labelled and non-labelled bonds based on the issuer’s transition commitment, as sometimes non-labelled bonds offer better risk-adjusted returns with strong issuer commitment.”

    “We should not get overly focused on format or label alone. It’s vital to evaluate each issuer, their financing strategy, and their holistic impact. Labelled bonds are helpful, but they can’t replace deep issuer-level analysis,” he added.



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email

    Related Posts

    SoftBank Seeks Billions in Overseas Bonds to Accelerate AI Expansion

    October 21, 2025

    Indonesia plans debut yuan bonds as dim sum issuance hits record

    October 21, 2025

    Buffalo Comptroller appealing judge’s ruling over her refusal to issue bonds

    October 21, 2025
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    The Shifting Landscape of Art Investment and the Rise of Accessibility: The London Art Exchange

    September 11, 2023

    Indonesia plans debut yuan bonds as dim sum issuance hits record

    October 21, 2025

    Charlie Cobham: The Art Broker Extraordinaire Maximizing Returns for High Net Worth Clients

    February 12, 2024

    The Unyielding Resilience of the Art Market: A Historical and Contemporary Perspective

    November 19, 2023
    Don't Miss
    Mutual Funds

    Mutual Funds KYC: How To Check And Update Your Status, Here’s A Step-by-Step Guide | Savings and Investments News

    October 22, 2025

    Last Updated:October 22, 2025, 09:23 ISTWithout KYC, you cannot invest in new funds or make…

    SBI Mutual Fund’s top 5 SIP plans – up to 20% CAGR in 10 years; Rs 10K investment turns into Rs 35 lakh – Money News

    October 22, 2025

    SoftBank Seeks Billions in Overseas Bonds to Accelerate AI Expansion

    October 21, 2025

    Indonesia plans debut yuan bonds as dim sum issuance hits record

    October 21, 2025
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • Vimeo
    EDITOR'S PICK

    Les ETF Ethereum enregistrent leur premier flux positif en semaines, ajoutant 40 000 ETH

    April 28, 2025

    Austin-Bergstrom International Airport to use new grant funds on Concourse B project

    October 28, 2024

    What are value funds? Ideal for investors who can face deep drawdowns | Personal Finance

    October 10, 2024
    Our Picks

    Mutual Funds KYC: How To Check And Update Your Status, Here’s A Step-by-Step Guide | Savings and Investments News

    October 22, 2025

    SBI Mutual Fund’s top 5 SIP plans – up to 20% CAGR in 10 years; Rs 10K investment turns into Rs 35 lakh – Money News

    October 22, 2025

    SoftBank Seeks Billions in Overseas Bonds to Accelerate AI Expansion

    October 21, 2025
    Most Popular

    🔥Juve target Chukwuemeka, Inter raise funds, Elmas bid in play 🤑

    August 20, 2025

    💵 Libra responds after Flamengo takes legal action and ‘freezes’ funds

    September 26, 2025

    ₹10,000 monthly SIP in this mutual fund has grown to ₹1.52 crore in 22 years

    September 17, 2025
    © 2025 Fund Focus News
    • Get In Touch
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.