Along with savings accounts and guaranteed investment certificates (GICs), bonds are the face of “safe” investing. While they’re susceptible to interest rate, inflation and default risks, most sources agree the predictable income and lower price volatility of bonds make them one of the safest choices for security in an unstable economic environment.
If most sources agree on something, likely, so will ChatGPT. When asked if dividend stocks are safer than bonds in retirement, the AI chatbot responded with the main differences between the two. However, it then opened up the discussion, claiming that while bonds are safer, dividend stocks aren’t “’unsafe’ — just different.”
Learn More: Can You Live Off Dividends? Here’s How Much You’d Need To Have Invested
Check Out: 9 Low-Effort Ways To Make Passive Income (You Can Start This Week)
Experts agree, and are quick to point out that both belong in your portfolio. “A big misconception I run into is that dividend stocks are bonds are two sides of the same coin,” said Zack Bernsdorf, veteran financial advisor and founder of Aspire Capital Management in Ohio. “While they can both provide retirement income, they are not the same thing and should not be approached that way from a strategic standpoint.”
Here’s what ChatGPT and a couple of professionals had to say about the perceived protection of bonds and dividend stocks.
What Does ChatGPT Say About Bonds?
Bonds, or debt securities, are a form of financing that entails the “lending” of money to a corporation or organization that issues a bond. This borrower acts as a lender in order to secure funds from investors. Whether corporate, municipal or Treasury, bonds provide a dependable income source with little risk to investors.
Aside from the protection against bankruptcy with company bonds (“Bondholders get paid before shareholders”) and lower volatility in price (“Fluctuate less than stocks”), ChatGPT stressed bonds’ predictable income as their main selling point, and retirees rely on bonds for income stability because they know interest payments, maturity date and, usually, the return on principal.
Bernsdorf agreed. “Bonds are historically known for stability and the cash you need in the immediate bucket,” he admitted, before adding, “However, the ‘bonds are safe’ theory has become a bit of a trap recently. In recent years, we have had a wake-up-call that when rates increase, even ‘safe’ bonds can take a hit.”
What About Dividend Stocks?
Dividend stocks pay profits to shareholders when a company has extra income that isn’t being used to grow the business. They are a way for investors to get a return on their contribution on a monthly, quarterly, semi-annual or annual basis.
Even blue-chip dividend stocks are riskier investments than bonds, because dividends aren’t legally guaranteed and are dependent upon business and market conditions. As ChatGPT noted, “A stock paying a 5% dividend can still: [a] Drop 30% in value. [b] Cut its dividend.” But they aren’t without their appeal.
“Dividend stocks a different animal entirely,” said Bernsdorf. “I prefer dividend ETFs for a number of reasons over individual stocks, but in general, I view them as a way to invest your assets for income with potential for ‘pay raises’ down the road to counteract inflation.”
According to Ivan Marchena, Senior Economist at global brokerage brand Just2Trade, “[D]ividend stocks are often misunderstood by investors. They aren’t like growth stocks that can fluctuate wildly in value over time.”
“Instead, dividend-paying stocks are generally characterized by solid earnings and market resilience,” he continued. “This makes them relatively similar to bonds, but with the potential to increase the value of their payouts in line with inflation.”
‘It’s Not Either/Or’
“The smartest move is combining both — not choosing one over the other,” wrote ChatGPT about bonds and dividend stocks. As a senior, you have to look at what you have and what you’ll need over the course of your retirement.
Bonds and dividend stocks are complimentary, and many investors still use the classic balanced portfolio of 60% stocks (including a portion in dividend payers to generate income while maintaining growth potential) and 40% bonds, even in this fickle market. As always, do some research and curate your portfolio to what suits you best.
“The biggest mistake I often see investors make is treating ‘income’ as if it’s safe,” said Bernsdorf. “You can get into just as much trouble chasing a double-digit yield as you can reaching for yield in junk bonds.
“It’s important to remember the difference between the assets, the risks inherent in each, and to ask yourself what the purpose of the investment is prior to putting your money to work,” he recommended.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice. It was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence and reviewed by our editorial team for accuracy. However, AI-generated content may be inaccurate, incomplete or outdated. You should independently verify important information through reliable sources before making any decisions based on this content.
More From MoneyLion: