When you find a company you want to support or one with good performance, have you ever considered options other than ‘buying stocks’?
Actually, there is one other way to provide money to the same company: ‘corporate bonds’.
Stocks and corporate bonds. Both are acts of ‘providing money to a company’, but your position becomes the exact opposite. When you buy stocks, you become an ‘owner (shareholder)’ of that company. When you buy corporate bonds, you become a ‘lender (creditor)’ who lends money to that company.
If you only buy stocks without knowing this difference, you may get exhausted by being swayed by price fluctuations. Conversely, even if you only know about corporate bonds, there are unexpected pitfalls.
In this article, I will honestly list the merits and demerits of corporate bonds and compare ‘how it differs from buying that company’s stock’ one by one. To give the conclusion first, it is not about which is superior, but that ‘as a way to place money, they have different roles’.
First, let’s grasp the mechanism of corporate bonds
Corporate bonds are like a promissory note issued by a company saying ‘please lend me money’. When issued, all conditions are determined.
・Interest rate (percentage of interest): How many percent of interest is paid annually
・Period (years until redemption): How many years later it will be returned
・Redemption amount: A promise that the face value (the exact amount lent) will be returned at maturity
For example, if you buy ‘1.5% annual interest, 5-year period, 1 million yen worth’, the design is that you receive 7,500 yen in interest every six months (15,000 yen per year), and 1 million yen is returned after 5 years (*this is a fictional example to explain the mechanism).
The biggest difference from bank deposits is that you are ‘lending directly to the company’ rather than ‘depositing’. That is why it often has a higher interest rate than deposits, but in exchange, there is no public protection like deposit insurance. This is the starting point for all merits and demerits.
Four merits of corporate bonds
The first is that interest is ‘guaranteed’. Even if you don’t worry about stock prices or earnings announcements, you will receive a fixed interest on a fixed date. Stock dividends can decrease or disappear depending on performance, but corporate bond interest is paid according to the contract as long as the company does not go bankrupt.
The second is that there is a promise that the face value will be returned at maturity. Since you can read ‘when and how much will be returned’ from the beginning, it is a design that is easy to use as a place for money where the purpose and timing are decided, such as education expenses or car replacement a few years later.
The third is the ‘order’ in case of an emergency. If a company goes bankrupt, the remaining assets are distributed in a fixed order. Creditors who lent money receive repayment before shareholders. Shareholders are last, and in many cases, there is nothing left. If you are ‘betting on the same company’, corporate bonds are in a defensive position.
The fourth is that price fluctuations are relatively small. The price of corporate bonds also moves daily, but what moves it is mainly market interest rates and the company’s creditworthiness. It is less likely to fluctuate significantly due to market sentiment like stocks, and the stress of watching price movements is reduced.
Four demerits of corporate bonds (I will write honestly here)
The first is that the principal is not guaranteed. If the issuing company goes bankrupt or defaults, there is a possibility that neither interest nor principal will be returned. In the past, there have been cases where corporate bonds of companies called major became almost worthless. A ‘promise’ is only valid if the company survives.
The second is that it is difficult to sell midway. For individual corporate bonds, there are few mechanisms to sell on the market at any time like stocks, and sales are mainly over-the-counter transactions with securities companies. Please think of it as something you buy on the premise of holding it until maturity.
The third is that the upper limit of profit is fixed. No matter how much the company grows, all you receive is the contracted interest. With stocks, there is a dream of it becoming 10 times larger, but there is no such dream with corporate bonds. It is a trade-off where you give up offense in exchange for defense.
The fourth is that it is vulnerable to inflation. Because the interest rate is fixed, in a phase where prices rise significantly, the real value of interest decreases. ‘The face value is returned’ and ‘purchasing power is protected’ are different stories.
Comparing the differences with stocks in 8 points
Using the same company as an example, here is a comparison of the differences in your position.
・Your position: Stock = Owner of the company (shareholder) / Corporate bond = Lender to the company (creditor)
・How money is provided: Stock = Investment (no promise of repayment) / Corporate bond = Loan (repaid at face value at maturity)
・Form of return: Stock = Dividends + capital gains (no upper limit) / Corporate bond = Interest only (determined at the start)
・In the event of bankruptcy: Stock = Last in line, almost nothing returned / Corporate bond = Repaid before shareholders
・Price movement: Stock = Large / Corporate bond = Relatively small (moves based on interest rates and creditworthiness)
・Participation in management: Stock = Voting rights at shareholder meetings / Corporate bond = None
・Duration: Stock = Indefinite until sold / Corporate bond = Maturity is fixed
・Minimum purchase amount: Stock = Many stocks can be bought from tens of thousands of yen / Corporate bond = Generally in units of 100,000 to 1 million yen
As you can see, what you should compare is not ‘which is more profitable,’ but rather ‘whether you want that money to play an aggressive role or a defensive role.’
3 numbers to check before buying corporate bonds
The first is the ‘credit rating.’ Credit rating agencies like R&I and JCR evaluate a company’s repayment ability, starting from AAA. The lower the credit rating of a company’s bonds, the higher the interest rate, but that is just a reflection of the risk. Jumping at ‘high interest rate = good deal’ is the most dangerous way to buy.
The second is the ‘balance between interest rate and duration.’ Even with the same interest rate, a 10-year bond and a 3-year bond differ in the number of years you must continue to trust that company.
The third is ‘whether it can be sold midway’ and ‘the issuer’s performance.’ Check the sale conditions in the prospectus and at least look at whether the company is making a profit in its most recent financial results.
This is suitable for people who think, ‘I want to grow money I plan to use in a few years more than a savings account, but I don’t want the price volatility of stocks.’ Conversely, this is not a place for living expenses or money you plan to use next year. Given the risk of bankruptcy and the difficulty of selling midway, it is intended for surplus funds that you can leave untouched until maturity.
Things to do today
Open the list of ‘corporate bonds’ on the website of the securities company where you have an account. Then, take a note of just three things for one bond that caught your interest: ‘credit rating, interest rate, and duration.’ Just by doing that, the difference between ‘buying stocks’ and ‘buying corporate bonds’ will become visible as numbers.
※ This article explains the mechanisms of corporate bonds and stocks and does not recommend the purchase of any specific issue. Corporate bonds are not principal-guaranteed products, and there is a possibility of losing the principal depending on the credit situation of the issuer. Please make investment decisions at your own risk after checking the prospectus.
Next time, we will compare the ‘Japanese Government Bonds for Individuals’ we covered previously with corporate bonds to clarify the differences between ‘lending to the government’ and ‘lending to a company.’
