Investors who have diversified their portfolios across local and offshore shares, bonds, property and cash do not necessarily need another asset class to improve their investment strategy. Actively managed exchange-traded funds (AMETFs) offer another option: introducing professional investment management into parts of an existing portfolio without abandoning index-tracking investments.
An AMETF is an exchange traded fund that you buy and sell on the JSE, just like any other ETF. The difference is that the portfolio is actively managed, with a portfolio manager making investment decisions on the fund, rather than simply replicating an index. The portfolio manager chooses what to hold, what to sell and adjusts the portfolio as market valuation changes. You get a manager’s expertise with the ease of access of an ETF.
For investors, the question is whether a manager’s investment decisions could add value to a particular part of their portfolio.
Eric Moyo, sales research analyst at Satrix, said investors with diversified portfolios did not need to start again when considering an AMETF.
“Your diversified portfolio may already be doing exactly what it was built to do, and an AMETF can work alongside it rather than replace it. The real question is where could a manager’s active decisions add something different or complementary in your portfolio?”.
Moyo uses the example of Thandiwe, a fictional 38-year-old teacher from Pretoria, to illustrate how an AMETF could complement an existing investment portfolio.
Thandiwe has been investing for several years and has allocated 25% of her portfolio to South African shares, 25% to global shares, 20% to a multi-asset fund, 15% to fixed income, 10% to property and 5% to cash.
Her portfolio is diversified across different asset classes and markets. When she considers an AMETF, she does not need to introduce another asset class or restructure her entire portfolio.
Instead, she could adjust how part of her existing fixed-income allocation is managed. For example, she could retain 10% in an index-tracking ETF and move the remaining 5% into a fixed-income AMETF. Her overall allocation to fixed income would remain at 15%.
The portfolio manager could adjust the fund’s holdings according to their assessment of interest rates, bond valuations and market conditions rather than simply following an index.
This flexibility may be particularly relevant in parts of the income market where a single index does not adequately capture the available investment opportunities.
Active management does not guarantee better performance
However, active management does not guarantee better performance. A portfolio manager may misjudge interest rate movements, select investments that underperform or take positions that expose investors to greater risk.
The S&P Dow Jones Indices SPIVA South Africa Mid-Year 2026 Scorecard highlights the difficulty active managers face in consistently outperforming market benchmarks.
The research found that 69% of actively managed South African equity funds underperformed the S&P South Africa Composite Capped Index during the first half of 2026. In the global equity category, 82% underperformed the S&P World Index over the same period.
Although the figures cover actively managed funds generally rather than AMETFs specifically, they illustrate why investors should not assume that paying for active management will translate into better returns.
Moyo cautioned against assuming that a manager’s involvement would necessarily produce superior results.
“A manager won’t always get their decisions right or deliver better returns.”
Fund fees should be assessed
Investors should assess a fund’s fees, risks and investment mandate before adding it to their portfolios. They should also consider whether it offers a genuinely different investment approach or simply duplicates exposure they already have, he said.
How much of a portfolio should be actively managed is another consideration. Moyo said there was no universal allocation suitable for every investor.
“There isn’t a single way to split between active and index tracking that works for everyone.”
Rather than starting with a percentage, investors should first establish what they want the investment to achieve. A fund intended to generate income may serve a different purpose from one targeting capital growth, according to Moyo.
“Once you know what you want the money to do, you can decide whether an AMETF is the right tool. How much you put in will depend on your goals and how much risk you’re comfortable with.”
Active and passive investments do not have to compete for space in a portfolio. Index-tracking ETFs can provide broad market exposure, while AMETFs allow managers to make investment decisions within specific mandates.
The decision ultimately comes down to whether the additional management approach justifies its costs and risks and contributes meaningfully to the investor’s overall strategy, Moyo said.
