When researching NISA, have you ever thought,
“I hear about mutual funds often, but what is an ETF?”
“Which one should I actually buy?”
At first, I also felt like,
“ETF…? That sounds more difficult than a mutual fund 😂”
But when I looked into it, I found that both mutual funds and ETFs have their own characteristics, and just knowing the differences makes it easier to choose products.
This time, I have summarized the differences between mutual funds and ETFs as simply as possible for NISA beginners.
—
What exactly are mutual funds and ETFs?
First, a quick overview.
A mutual fund is a product where an investment management company pools money collected from many investors and invests it in stocks, bonds, etc.
On the other hand,
ETF stands for “Exchange Traded Fund.”
As the name suggests, it is a type of mutual fund, but it has the characteristic of being tradable on a stock exchange just like a stock.
In other words,
ETF = a mutual fund that can be traded like a stock
is an easy way to think about it at first.
—
Differences between mutual funds and ETFs
Here is a table showing the major differences 👇
Mutual Fund ETF
Trading Basically once-a-day net asset value Traded during market hours
Price Net asset value Market price
Accumulation Easy to set up automatic accumulation Depends on the product/securities company
Diversification Possible Possible
Distributions Some products allow reinvestment Some products pay out distributions
Trading method Purchased as a mutual fund Ordered like a stock
*Mechanisms and availability vary by product.
—
① The biggest difference is the “way to buy”
Mutual funds are characterized by the ease of setting up accumulation by specifying an amount, such as
“50,000 yen per month”
or
“10,000 yen per month.”
For example, you can set it up to automatically accumulate 30,000 yen every month.
On the other hand, ETFs are basically traded on the market just like stocks.
The image is that you place an order, such as
“I want to buy at this price now.”
This difference is quite significant when you actually use them.
—
② The way prices are determined is also different
Mutual funds are basically traded based on that day’s net asset value.
On the other hand, ETF prices move in real-time on the market, just like stocks.
Therefore, with ETFs, you can place orders while considering timing, such as
“Buy now”
or
“Buy when the price drops a little.”
However, trading while watching prices closely is not necessarily suitable for long-term investment.
In long-term asset formation, it is also important not to be swayed by short-term price fluctuations.
—
③ Ease of accumulation
This is also important for beginners to compare.
Mutual funds are easy to set up for accumulation, allowing you to operate with
“Once set up, it’s purchased automatically every month.”
For people busy with work, housework, or childcare, this “automation” can be a major benefit.
Since it is important to continue investing for a long time, it is also important to create a “system that you can continue without strain.”
—
④ Differences in distributions
Some ETFs pay out distributions.
On the other hand, some mutual funds do not pay out distributions and continue to operate within the fund.
What you want to be careful about here is that
“High distributions does not necessarily mean it is profitable.”
It is important not to look only at the amount of distributions, but to look at things like:
* What it is investing in
* How much the fees are
* How the price moves
* How it is doing in total
—
⑤ Which one is better in the end?
This is the part you are most curious about, right?
But I cannot say
“Mutual funds are definitely better”
or
“ETFs are definitely better.”
This is because it depends on your purpose and investment style.
For example:
People who find mutual funds easy to use:
* Want to accumulate steadily every month
* Want to automate
* Want to start with a small amount
* Want to continue calmly for the long term
People who find ETFs easy to use:
* Want to trade like stocks
* Want to trade at real-time prices
* Want to operate while receiving distributions
* Are used to placing orders themselves
These are the differences. Of course, these are just general characteristics.
—
What do I do?
I am currently accumulating S&P 500 mutual funds every month in my NISA.
And in the future, I plan to increase my investment in high-dividend stocks.
In other words, I am building assets not just with
“mutual funds only,”
but in the form of
“mutual funds + high-dividend stocks.”
This is also not a case of
“this method is the correct answer!”
I am combining investment destinations according to my own goals and way of thinking.
—
If you are lost, think from the “purpose”
When choosing an investment product, instead of thinking from
“Which is popular?”
or
“Which is profitable?”
first try thinking about
“What am I investing for?”
For example, if you want to
“accumulate for a long period for retirement,”
think about a system that is easy to continue for a long time.
If you want to
“operate while receiving dividends,”
research the mechanism of distributions and dividends.
If you think in the order of Purpose → Product like this, it will be harder to get lost when choosing products.
—
Summary
Both mutual funds and ETFs are products that can be used for diversified investment, but there are differences in trading methods and how prices are determined.
If you want to remember it roughly, it is okay to start with the image that:
Mutual funds = easy to accumulate, easy to continue steadily
ETFs = can be traded on the market like stocks
The important thing is to think,
“Which one fits my investment purpose?” rather than “Which is the correct answer?”
I am also studying investment one by one while asking AI.
“What happens if you invest while asking AI?”
I will continue to record my actual asset formation 📈
Let’s build assets steadily together!
*This article is intended to provide information for investment beginners and does not recommend any specific product or investment method. Investment carries the risk of principal loss. Please make final investment decisions yourself.