Introduction
When researching investments, you often come across the idea that index funds are superior to active funds.
In fact, it is widely considered difficult for most active funds to outperform the market average over the long term.
Because of this, many people likely choose the “All-Country (All-Country World Equity Index Fund)” because it allows for low-cost, diversified investment in stocks around the world.
Of course, I believe the All-Country fund is an excellent investment product.
However, there is something that concerns me a little.
Are you perhaps thinking that “index funds are safe” or “it’s fine if I just buy an All-Country fund” based solely on looking at past performance and cost comparisons?
In this article, I will write about my own thoughts through a comparison of active and index funds.
1. Should you decide where to invest based only on past results?
The appeal of index funds is, above all, the ability to invest in the entire market at a low cost.
There is no need to spend a lot of time analyzing individual companies, and I think it is a very rational choice for those aiming for long-term asset formation.
On the other hand, I suspect there are people who accept the conclusion that “index funds are superior” based on past data without fully understanding the reasons or risks involved.
What is important is not just the conclusion of which is better, but understanding why that result occurred and that the same result is not guaranteed in the future. I believe.
Active funds also have the potential to outperform the market average depending on their investment policy and stock selection. However, many products have high fees, and the manager’s judgment is not always successful.
Conversely, index funds are also affected if the entire market declines.
Since both have advantages and disadvantages, I would like to avoid making judgments based solely on superficial comparisons.
2. What risks does the All-Country fund have?
The great appeal of the All-Country fund is the ability to diversify investments across stocks around the world.
It aims to capture the growth of the global economy as a whole without concentrating assets in specific countries or companies.
However, just because you are diversifying your investments does not mean you can avoid losses.
For example, there are risks such as the following:
-
Risk of a global stock market decline: If the global economy falls into a recession, stocks in multiple countries could decline simultaneously.
-
Concentration in US stocks: Even with a global equity fund, products that invest based on market capitalization may have a high proportion of US stocks.
-
Foreign exchange risk: Since the focus is on foreign stocks, if the yen strengthens, the asset value in yen terms may decrease.
-
Possibility of holding overvalued stocks: In market-capitalization-weighted indices, companies whose stock prices have risen significantly have a higher weighting. Even for excellent companies, depending on the purchase price, future returns may fall below expectations.
I believe it is important to invest with an understanding of these characteristics.
3. All Country includes both good and not-so-good companies
All Country is a convenient product that allows you to hold a wide range of companies around the world.
However, not all of the companies included are necessarily attractive investment targets for you.
There are companies with high growth potential, as well as companies with slowing growth or those facing difficult business environments.
Of course, index funds are not products that judge the quality of individual companies. The point is to hold a wide range of assets according to the rules of the index.
Also, companies with deteriorating performance are not included forever; the constituent stocks are replaced through index reviews.
Even so, I would like to understand the point that you will be investing in companies you do not find attractive as long as they are constituents of the index.
I do not mean to deny All Country.
However, I do not think that just because it is diversified around the world, you do not need to think about the companies or investment destinations you hold.
4. Be careful with the idea that ‘it’s okay because it’s diversified’
Diversified investment is an important risk management method in investing.
By investing in multiple companies and countries rather than concentrating your investment in a single company, you can suppress the impact of poor performance by a specific company.
However, diversified investment is not a panacea.
If the entire market drops significantly, your assets may decrease even if you are invested in a wide range of stocks.
Also, increasing the number of investments and completely eliminating risk are two different things.
I believe what is important is not to feel at ease just because of the fact that you are diversified, but to understand what kind of risks you are taking on.
And even when stock prices fall sharply, I want to be in a position where I can explain why I hold that product.
5. The option of researching companies yourself and buying at a price you are comfortable with
After reading this far, you might think, “So, are individual stocks better?”
Of course, individual stocks also carry significant risks.
Company analysis takes time, and no matter how much you research, you cannot accurately predict future performance or stock prices.
If you concentrate on a single company, there is a possibility that your assets will decrease significantly due to that company’s poor performance.
Even so, I believe that researching individual stocks has value beyond just asset management.
For example, reading a company’s financial statements and checking the trends in sales and EPS (earnings per share). Investigating competitive advantages and financial conditions to think about whether they can continue to grow profits. Checking dividend history and policies to judge whether shareholder returns are sustainable.
Furthermore, no matter how excellent a company is, if the stock price is too high, I will pass on purchasing it.
By repeating this process, I believe your eye for companies and your understanding of the economy will deepen.
Researching, thinking, and purchasing at a price you can be satisfied with. I believe that experience itself leads to your own personal growth.I think.
Of course, this does not mean that choosing individual stocks will yield higher returns than index funds. Just because you studied does not guarantee that you can beat the market average.
Even so, as long as you are investing your own money, I feel there is meaning in thinking proactively about where you invest.
6. In the end, which is better, active funds or index funds?
My view is that neither one is absolutely correct.
If you want to capture the growth of the global economy without much effort, low-cost index funds are a strong option.
On the other hand, for those who have their own investment policy and want to analyze companies to choose their investments, there are also options like individual stocks or active funds.
However, if you choose an active fund, you need to check its investment policy, fees, performance, and risks. If you choose individual stocks, not only company analysis but also diversification and capital management are essential.
The important thing is not to decide just because someone else recommends it or because its past performance was good.
Understanding what you are investing in, what risks you are taking on, and what you are expecting is, I believe, important.
Conclusion
All Country is a very attractive option for long-term asset formation.
I myself fully understand the rationality of index funds.
However, rather than thinking ‘All Country is safe’ or ‘It’s fine because it’s diversified,’ I want to understand its mechanisms and risks, and invest only after I am convinced in my own way.
And, although the hurdle may be a bit high, I feel it is also worth challenging yourself to research individual companies, judge their value based on your own criteria, and purchase them at a price you are comfortable with.
The purpose of investing is not just to increase your money.
Thinking about money, learning about companies, and understanding economic movements. Isn’t enhancing your own knowledge and judgment in that process also one of the attractions of investing?
What criteria do you use to choose between index funds and active funds?
Also, do you think researching individual stocks has value beyond asset formation?
I would love to hear your thoughts as well.
