Investors looking to park money for short-term financial goals can consider debt funds and arbitrage funds. However, the two mutual fund categories follow different investment strategies, carry different risks and have different tax treatments. The choice depends on how long investors can remain invested, their financial goals and their tax position.
Viral Bhatt, founder of Money Mantra, said investors looking to park money for less than a year could consider debt funds. Those who can remain invested for more than a year could also consider arbitrage funds.
Debt funds: How they work
Debt funds are mutual funds that invest in fixed-income instruments such as government securities, corporate bonds and money-market instruments. They aim to generate returns through interest income and changes in the prices of the securities in their portfolios.
Different types of debt funds cater to different investment horizons. Liquid funds generally invest in short-term money-market instruments, while ultra-short-duration, money-market and short-duration funds invest in securities with different maturity profiles.
Bhatt said investors looking to park money for less than a year could consider debt funds. However, they should assess the securities held by a fund and the risks associated with them before investing.
Debt funds are not entirely risk-free. Their returns can be affected by changes in interest rates and the credit quality of the securities in which they invest. A rise in interest rates can affect bond prices, while a borrower failing to meet its repayment obligations can expose the fund to credit risk.
Arbitrage funds: How they generate returns
Arbitrage funds aim to benefit from price differences between a stock in the cash market and its futures contract. They buy the stock in the cash market and take an opposite position in the futures market to capture the difference in prices.
For instance, if a stock is trading at ₹100 in the cash market and its futures contract is trading at ₹102, a fund may buy the stock at ₹100 and sell the futures contract at ₹102. The difference represents the potential arbitrage spread, before transaction costs and other expenses.
Bhatt said investors who can remain invested for more than a year could also consider arbitrage funds. However, returns depend on the arbitrage opportunities available in the market and are not guaranteed.
Debt funds vs arbitrage funds: Understanding the differences
The two categories differ in their investment strategies and risk factors. Debt funds invest in fixed-income instruments and are exposed to interest-rate and credit risks. Arbitrage funds use positions in the cash and futures markets to capture price differences.
Their tax treatment also differs. Debt funds and arbitrage funds follow separate tax rules. Arbitrage funds are treated as equity-oriented funds for tax purposes, subject to applicable holding-period rules. The taxation of debt funds depends on the applicable provisions, including the nature and date of investment.
Bhatt advised investors to compare the tax structures and potential returns of the two categories before making a decision. Investors should consider the post-tax return rather than comparing only the headline returns.
Arbitrage funds: Impact of market volatility on returns
Market volatility can influence the price differences between stocks in the cash and futures markets. Bhatt said arbitrage funds may offer better return potential during periods of higher market volatility.
However, higher volatility does not necessarily translate into better returns. The availability of arbitrage opportunities and the price differences between the cash and futures markets also matter.
Investors should also remember that arbitrage funds are not the same as fixed deposits. Their returns are market-linked and can vary depending on the opportunities available.
Debt funds or arbitrage funds: Where should you invest
The choice between debt funds and arbitrage funds depends on the investment horizon, risk appetite and tax considerations.
Bhatt said investors with an investment horizon of less than a year could consider debt funds. Those who can remain invested for more than a year can also look at arbitrage funds.
NOTE TO READERS
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice. Readers should consult certified experts before making any investment decisions.
