Thanksgiving often brings a sense of dread. Not because of a burnt turkey, but due to the uncomfortable political discussions that split the table down the middle.
It makes it really awkward to ask, “can you pass the gravy? ” after a heated conversation over whether abortion should be determined by the federal government or the states. This dynamic mirrors larger political divides in our society, which are undeniable.
Political disagreements can strain relationships, whether you’re arguing with your uncle about the significance of electing the first woman president or your cousin lecturing you on why “illegal aliens” should stay out of the country — we’ve all had our fair share of tension-filled conversations.
As we navigate these charged conversations, it’s worth examining the underlying currents that fuel our beliefs. Understanding the emotional and social factors at play might help us not just survive Thanksgiving dinner, but perhaps even find a common ground amid the clamor of clashing ideologies.
A consistent question that runs through my head is: what drives us to believe what we believe, and how can we engage with one another without losing sight of the bonds that unite us?
I vividly remember the moment I discovered my voice amid the political tumult of my upbringing. Growing up in a households steeped in politics — my father a former Secret Service officer, my stepmother an original staffer for former President Barack Obama and my “yaya” a fierce and confident woman always teaching me to stand up for my beliefs — meant I was politically motivated from an early age.
I am surrounded by both sides of the political spectrum, which has not only tested my patience, but helped me develop a sense of what I believe in and learn how to approach heated political conversations more thoughtfully.
From what I found most helpful navigating these situations, is that it requires setting healthy boundaries, knowing when to engage in discussions and when to step back, especially when emotions are high. It’s crucial to choose the right time and context for these conversations, creating space for thoughtful, rather than reactionary, dialogue.
Additionally, active listening plays a vital role, allowing you to understand the other person’s perspective, which is often shaped by personal experiences or fears. Finding common ground, such as shared values like fairness or community, can help bridge ideological gaps. Instead of trying to persuade, their viewpoint.
It’s easy to get caught up in the symbols and ideologies that separate us, but it’s essential to remember that behind every belief is a person, behind every vote, there are real-world consequences.
At the University of Wisconsin-Madison, Larry Czeponis, an intelligent and witty teaching assistant in an elections and voting behavior political science course, shared an insightful perspective on this dynamic, highlighting the power of finding common ground in discussions even when there are stark differences.
Czeponis told The Daily Cardinal he has always stood ground in his views since he was young, growing up progressive in a small conservative town.
Enjoy what you’re reading? Get content from The Daily Cardinal delivered to your inbox
“It’s interesting with my friends, when we get back together…we just never talk about politics,” Czeponis said.
In 2020, navigating political discussions in group settings posed challenges. Czeponis recalled feeling isolated in a group of 12 friends facing jokes and ridicule for his political views.
“We both will agree that lower-income or middle-class people don’t get a fair stake in government…Democrats and Republicans are beholden to corporate interests in some way,” he said.
By recognizing that many people regardless of political affiliation have common concerns, Czeponis emphasized the possibility of productive conversations.
“Everything in life is political, but life isn’t all about politics,” he said.
This perspective reminds us that while political beliefs inevitably influence many aspects of our lives, they should not define our entire existence, or determine the value of our relationships during Thanksgiving.
Maeghan Chase, a confident and outspoken senior at UW-Madison, told the Cardinal that setting boundaries in relationships where political opinions clash is important.
“I honestly think if people listened to each other and really tried to understand where the other was coming from, we’d realize we aren’t all as divided as we believe we are,” Chase said.
Chase also said individuals should try to not interrupt one another during political discussions because it fosters a sense of being heard and understood, rather than the conversation becoming a battle of opinions.
“It’s so important to let the other person say their perspective without being interrupted…this goes for friends, family, boyfriends, girlfriends, etc. And it’s way harder than it sounds,” she said.
She recalled a piece of advice from a former boss: “God gave us two ears and one mouth for a reason. Listen more than you talk.”
This simple yet profound approach, Chase explained, not only applies to political conversations but is a valuable tool for maintaining healthy relationships in all areas of life.
Over the years, I have observed that people find pride in their political stance, and when you disagree with their opinion, it’s almost doing a disservice to their identity in a way. During election season, we see it everywhere — neighbors proudly displaying “Harris for President” yard signs, “Blue Lives Matter” flags on cars or wearing MAGA hats at the grocery store. Behind these symbols are people who take pride in their beliefs, or perhaps find a sense of belonging in something bigger than themselves.
However, just like rooting for a favorite sports team, people rally behind their political causes. But sometimes, we lose sight of the fact that a presidential election isn’t a sporting match. It’s important to remember that, beneath the signs and slogans, these political decisions affect everyday people, we can’t lose sight of the humanity at heart of these conversations, because that’s what truly matters.
Be proud of your voice, but don’t waste any more time — nurture your family and friends, relationships are far more important than any debate.
The Daily Cardinal has been covering the University and Madison community since 1892. Please consider giving today.