A bond can pay its 5% coupon exactly as promised and still leave you with a negative return for the year.
The coupon is only part of the calculation. Changes in the bond’s market value matter too, particularly if you need to sell before maturity. That distinction deserves attention when the income on offer looks attractive.
ADVERTISEMENT
CONTINUE READING BELOW
On 24 September 2026, the US Treasury’s published par yield curve showed two-year yields of 4.87%, 10-year yields of 5.18% and 30-year yields of 5.47%. These are indicative annualised market yields before investor fees and taxes; an individual purchase may be priced differently.
Moving from two years to thirty years added 0.60 percentage points of yield. It also introduced substantially greater sensitivity to changes in market yields. Whether that trade-off is attractive depends on how long the money can remain invested and what the investor expects the bond to do.
Read/Listen: The 5% bond yield reality
Separate the coupon from the yield
The coupon determines the interest payments on a conventional fixed-rate bond. A 5% coupon on $100 of face value pays $5 a year, whatever price the investor paid for the bond.
Yield to maturity incorporates those payments, the purchase price and the amount due at maturity. A bond bought below its repayment value can have a yield above its coupon rate because part of the prospective return comes from that discount closing.
The quoted yield is therefore not necessarily the cash income received each year.
Yield to maturity summarises the return implied by the scheduled cash flows if the bond is held to maturity and the issuer pays as promised. Compounding the proceeds also depends on the rates at which coupons can be reinvested.
Spending those coupons provides income without compounding them.
The same income can produce different returns
Consider a hypothetical 10-year bond bought for $100, paying a $5 coupon annually and repaying $100 at maturity. After one year, the first coupon has been paid and nine years remain. The market value of those remaining payments depends on the yield buyers require.
| Market yield after one year | Bond value after the coupon payment | One-year dollar total return |
|---|---|---|
| Falls to 4% | $107.44 | 12.44% |
| Remains at 5% | $100.00 | 5.00% |
| Rises to 6% | $93.20 | −1.80% |
Author’s calculations, rounded. Total return includes the first $5 coupon. This hypothetical bond pays annually, unlike the semiannual coupons on US Treasury notes and bonds. The example assumes no default or early redemption and excludes fees, taxes and currency movements.
The investor receives the same $5 in every scenario. The total return differs because the value of the remaining payments changes.
When newly available bonds offer higher yields, an existing bond’s fixed payments become less attractive. Its price falls to offer buyers a competitive return. When required yields fall, those payments become more valuable.
The change in market value affects the holding-period return even without a sale. Income cushions a price decline, but the table shows why it may not cover the loss.
Read: Is the US heading for 6% yields on the 10-year?
Match the maturity to the job
Bond managers use duration to estimate sensitivity to changes in yields. For otherwise comparable bonds, a longer maturity generally means more price sensitivity. That can bring larger gains when yields fall and larger losses when they rise.
ADVERTISEMENT:
CONTINUE READING BELOW
Shorter maturities reduce that sensitivity, but leave another uncertainty. A two-year treasury does not secure today’s yield for ten years. When it matures, the reinvestment rate may be higher or lower.
A longer bond fixes its payments further into the future, which can be useful when those payments match a future expense.
Holding an individual bond to maturity provides a defined payment schedule, assuming the issuer honours its obligations and the bond is not redeemed early.
Repayment is at face value, which may differ from the purchase price. Inflation can erode the purchasing power of those fixed payments.
A conventional bond fund usually replaces maturing securities and has no single date with a fixed repayment. A fund that targets a particular maturity year does not automatically guarantee its final payout. Read portfolio yield alongside duration, holdings, costs and the fund’s mandate.
Ask what the extra yield pays for
Corporate bonds introduce credit risk as well as interest-rate risk. On 23 September 2026, the investment-grade ICE BofA US Corporate Index had an effective yield of 5.83% and an option-adjusted spread of 0.77 percentage points over the relevant Treasury curve.
That spread allows for embedded options and helps assess compensation for credit and liquidity risks. It is not a promised extra return. A high corporate yield can largely reflect high government bond yields, rather than generous compensation for lending to companies.
An investor can consequently lose money on a corporate bond when concerns about the borrower increase, even without a rise in Treasury yields.
For a South African investor, all these calculations describe dollar outcomes. Converting the result into rands introduces exchange-rate exposure unless it has been hedged. The currency in which the money will eventually be spent belongs in the decision too.
Read: Bonds, shaken and stirred
Before choosing a bond or fund, establish what income is expected, when capital is needed and how much change in its market value the plan can absorb.
The highest yield is easy to identify. The harder task is deciding whether the extra income pays you enough for what can go wrong.
This is general educational commentary, not personal financial, investment or tax advice. The appropriate approach depends on individual circumstances, objectives, time horizon and capacity for loss. Market yields change, and historical results do not guarantee future outcomes.
