There Is A 20% Yield S&P 500 ETF That Crushes Most Covered Call ETFs

Quick Read

• XPAY is not a covered call ETF: The fund uses FLEX options and collateral cash rather than systematically selling upside through covered calls.

• The 20% distribution is largely return of capital: That can improve tax deferral for some investors, though it also means principal may decline over time.

• Total return has held up surprisingly well: XPAY has trailed SPY only modestly while significantly outperforming the long-term return profile of many traditional covered call ETFs.

• Act now: the analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named his top 10 AI stocks — and TPAY didn’t make the cut. Grab the names FREE today.

The risk-and-return profile of most covered call ETFs isn’t especially appealing. You cap your upside while retaining most of the downside exposure. On top of that, the distributions investors receive are not free money. The ETF’s net asset value (NAV) falls by the amount distributed on the ex date, and those payouts can create taxable events.

Still, covered call ETFs remain extremely popular, particularly among retirees. A large reason comes down to behavior. Many investors are comfortable spending dividends and distributions, but dislike selling shares to fund withdrawals, even though the two are mathematically very similar. 

If the goal is a hands-off decumulation solution, however, there may be better options available. One fund that has been on my radar for some time is the Roundhill S&P 500 Target 20 Managed Distribution ETF (XPAY). The objective is straightforward: pay 20% annually to investors. The majority of those distributions are currently classified as return of capital.

Importantly, Roundhill explicitly notes that XPAY is generally not appropriate for investors who do not want their principal to decline over time or who are uncomfortable receiving return-of-capital distributions. This is primarily a decumulation-focused strategy. What’s interesting is that despite targeting such a large payout, XPAY’s total return has remained surprisingly competitive.

Act now: the analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named his top 10 AI stocks — and TPAY didn’t make the cut. Grab the names FREE today.

Over the 1.63-year period from Oct. 31, 2024, through June 17, 2026, XPAY generated a cumulative total return of 30.64%, compared with 32.63% for the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY). It still lagged the benchmark, but by far less than many covered call ETFs over a similar period.

The reason becomes clearer once you understand how XPAY actually works. On that note, I I recently spoke with Thomas DeFazio, ETF Strategist at Roundhill Investments, about the structure behind XPAY. Here’s what he told me.

How XPAY Generates Its Distribution

The key distinction is that XPAY is not a covered call ETF. Unlike traditional covered call strategies, the fund is not systematically selling upside in exchange for option premiums. Instead, XPAY uses SPY FLEX options to obtain its S&P 500 exposure.

According to DeFazio, the fund purchases call options that provide the desired level of S&P 500 participation while leaving a substantial portion of assets in cash.  The result is a portfolio that can maintain equity exposure while simultaneously retaining a large pool of cash that supports the fund’s managed distribution policy via return of capital.

Another important detail involves the underlying exposure. XPAY uses FLEX options linked to SPY rather than SPX index options. According to DeFazio, this allows the ETF to utilize the in-kind creation and redemption mechanism that makes ETFs so tax efficient.

In simple terms, authorized participants can exchange baskets of securities rather than forcing the ETF to sell positions and realize taxable gains. This helps minimize realized capital gains inside the fund and supports the return of capital framework.

A Closer Look At XPAY’s Yield

XPAY currently manages approximately $158 million in assets and charges a 0.49% expense ratio. As of June 17, 2026, the fund’s annualized distribution rate stood at 20.39%, paid monthly. According to the most recent Form 19a-1 notice, 100% of the distribution was estimated to be return of capital. Investors should remember that this classification remains only an estimate until year-end tax reporting is finalized on Form 1099-DIV.

For retirees and decumulation-focused investors, return of capital can offer advantages. Unlike ordinary income distributions, return of capital is generally not immediately taxable. Instead, it reduces an investor’s adjusted cost basis in the fund. Taxes are deferred until shares are eventually sold, assuming the adjusted cost basis remains above zero. That does not eliminate taxes entirely. It simply postpones them. Even so, many investors may find this preferable to receiving distributions taxed as ordinary income.

What stands out most about XPAY is not necessarily the yield itself, but how competitive its total return has been despite distributing such a large amount of cash. The fund still trails SPY, which is unsurprising given management fees and the costs associated with maintaining the options overlay. Yet compared with many covered call ETFs, XPAY has retained substantially more upside participation. For investors seeking an aggressive, hands-off decumulation strategy, that makes it one of the more interesting income-oriented ETFs currently available.

Act now: the analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named his top 10 AI stocks — and TPAY didn’t make the cut. Grab the names FREE today.