Close Menu
Fund Focus News
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • [Investment] Why mutual funds drop on days when US stocks rise: The 1-day time lag|許す!
    • France orders 50,000 artillery shells from KNDS and co-funds plan to triple capacity at its La Chapelle-Saint-Ursin plant
    • What actively managed ETFs could add to a diversified portfolio
    • Robert Pattinson’s Bond Movie Could Shoot at Pinewood Studios
    • QCP Says Bitcoin Needs Tech Calm, Steady Rates and Fresh ETF Money to Recover — BigGo Finance
    • 5 Mutual Funds Offering Daily SIPs Starting at ₹10: Returns, Risk and Other Details
    • Investing in railways – the best stocks to buy
    • Amazon MGM Studios in discussions to film Bond 26 starring Robert Pattinson at UK’s Pinewood Studios
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Fund Focus News
    • Home
    • Bonds
    • ETFs
    • Funds
    • Investments
    • Mutual Funds
    • Property Investments
    • SIP
    Fund Focus News
    Home»Funds»Funding dispute is going nowhere
    Funds

    Funding dispute is going nowhere

    October 10, 2024


    The disagreement among Dallas Area Rapid Transit member cities has shifted from a healthy debate to a very disagreeable and dangerous dispute. If cooler heads don’t soon prevail, the current path could very well lead to a diminished agency incapable of supporting basic public transportation services to transit-dependent residents.

    It is odd and surprising that Plano would lead the charge to lower the sales tax that funds DART at the very moment of the pending introduction in 2025 of the Silver Line commuter rail system, which will provide two new stations in Plano and direct service to the University of Texas at Dallas and DFW International Airport.

    Even more surprising is that Plano would suggest this without even inquiring what impact it would have on the agency’s 20-year financial plan, approved by the DART board, which has very capably guided decisions regarding capital investment and service plans.

    To be clear, the 1% sales tax currently being collected will remain for the foreseeable future. And, no, the Texas Legislature cannot provide Plano or other cities with relief from this obligation. The Master Debt Resolution adopted by DART at the inception of bond issuance makes that quite clear.

    Opinion

    Get smart opinions on the topics North Texans care about.

    The Texas Constitution is very specific about the sacrosanct nature of contracts. Should the Legislature attempt to modify an existing bond covenant, it would trigger concerns among virtually all local government debt issuers in Texas — especially so among the institutional investors who purchased DART bonds and rely upon their assured repayment.

    As harsh as this may sound, what Plano is asking is for DART to break its contract, ignore the concerns of its creditors and start a cascading crisis of public finance.

    While it is true DART could work around the covenant by refunding all outstanding debt and then rewriting the Master Debt Resolution, the cost of refinancing, along with increasing interest costs, would be in the hundreds of millions. It would most likely trigger an immediate downgrade in bond ratings, which would increase interest rates even more. It might also lead to a bondholder lawsuit brought by major institutional holders of DART debt. It is not going to happen.

    Review needed

    It is difficult to understand how Plano could arrive at a recommendation to reduce the sales tax without having undertaken a full fiscal and service review.

    What Plano and other cities have suggested — lowering the rate to three-quarters of one cent — has no supporting analysis other than the argument that some member cities would like to obtain funds for other uses.

    The impact of reduced funding levels on service levels must be determined and brought forward in a fully transparent manner. Major service plan changes and large service-provider contract deliberations usually consume a full year and often two years.

    Plano and the other suburbs in support of reducing DART funding should request a full review of the impact of their proposal throughout the DART service area with a goal of finding common ground. Some patience and careful reflection is advised.

    Let fairness prevail

    To be fair, Plano and the other suburbs in the system are making a valid argument that should be addressed. A system in place for nearly four decades will naturally see demographic and economic circumstances change dramatically over that time period.

    When DART was created, it was probably unimaginable that Plano, a small suburban community, would grow to a population of 289,000 and become the second-largest contributor of sales tax in the entire system, after Dallas. It was also likely unimaginable that the suburban jurisdictions would generate, in the aggregate, total sales tax contributions larger than the city of Dallas. It is entirely reasonable to assume that funding allocations and the mix and amount of mobility services provided might get out of balance when considered against the original estimates.

    But rather than an arbitrary 25% cut, the member cities would be much better served by setting up a “balanced service levels by city” policy framework based upon some agreed-to fiscal and social equity principles. This is currently done in Seattle, Salt Lake City and Phoenix. It is tedious and occasionally contentious, but allows arguments about fairness to be defused more calmly.

    That approach would gradually shift resources to suburban areas. It would also likely require providing each participating jurisdiction with more control over the choice of modes and levels of service (bus, rail, on demand, paratransit) it prefers.

    The DART board has the full authority to undertake this level of policy development and adoption without the need to go to the Legislature. Hopefully the elected officials and their appointed representatives on the DART board of directors can be convinced to consider these other less contentious and damaging options.

    A solution

    There is a legislative solution to Plano’s problem already in place under Chapter 452, Section 2.2 (6) of the Texas Transportation code. That chapter provides the opportunity for a member city to conduct a pullout election and withdraw entirely from the agency.

    Sales tax would continue to be collected until accrued debt and liabilities allocated to the city have been fully covered. In Plano’s case, that would likely take 15 years or more.

    The statute also stipulates that service to the jurisdiction would immediately cease following a successful pullout election. The consequences of that are fairly stark. It is understandable that Plano would like to avoid the pushback that would most likely generate.

    If Plano wants to get relief from the pullout requirements, it could consider a legislative modification to provide one or two alternative wind-down methods. These could include a longer paydown period with some earlier access to a portion of the sales tax, and possibly provide for re-entry into a contract for services. This would provide an option to retain access to the upcoming Silver Line service and vital paratransit services.

    As it is, Plano’s proposed legislative solution is tortured and difficult to implement. It would impose new burdens on other member cities. It would consume unnecessary amounts of time and money in the upcoming legislative session, generate a great deal of animus among the DART member cities and the outcome would almost assuredly be defeat.

    David Leininger is founder and CEO of Leininger Analytics. He previously served as CFO and interim CEO at Dallas Area Rapid Transit.

    We welcome your thoughts in a letter to the editor. See the guidelines and submit your letter here. If you have problems with the form, you can submit via email at letters@dallasnews.com



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email

    Related Posts

    France orders 50,000 artillery shells from KNDS and co-funds plan to triple capacity at its La Chapelle-Saint-Ursin plant

    November 21, 2026

    NAIC Fall Meeting: What CLO, Rated Fund And CFO Market Participants Need To Know

    November 21, 2026

    How do you fund a new performance art museum in L.A.? By selling chocolate butt plugs.

    November 21, 2026
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    What actively managed ETFs could add to a diversified portfolio

    November 21, 2026

    Amazon MGM Studios in discussions to film Bond 26 starring Robert Pattinson at UK’s Pinewood Studios

    November 21, 2026

    Property firm targets youth with investment education platform

    November 20, 2026

    France orders 50,000 artillery shells from KNDS and co-funds plan to triple capacity at its La Chapelle-Saint-Ursin plant

    November 21, 2026
    Don't Miss
    Mutual Funds

    [Investment] Why mutual funds drop on days when US stocks rise: The 1-day time lag|許す!

    November 21, 2026

    Why does my mutual fund drop on a day when US stocks go up?The price…

    France orders 50,000 artillery shells from KNDS and co-funds plan to triple capacity at its La Chapelle-Saint-Ursin plant

    November 21, 2026

    What actively managed ETFs could add to a diversified portfolio

    November 21, 2026

    Robert Pattinson’s Bond Movie Could Shoot at Pinewood Studios

    November 21, 2026
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • Vimeo
    EDITOR'S PICK

    Do YOU have what it takes to be a Premium Bonds millionaire? How much £1m winners held, where they live… and how long it took them to win

    October 7, 2025

    What To Know Before Taking Another Sip Of Maker’s Mark

    September 5, 2025

    Physical bars, coins or ETFs? The best ways for retirees to own gold in 2026

    January 30, 2026
    Our Picks

    [Investment] Why mutual funds drop on days when US stocks rise: The 1-day time lag|許す!

    November 21, 2026

    France orders 50,000 artillery shells from KNDS and co-funds plan to triple capacity at its La Chapelle-Saint-Ursin plant

    November 21, 2026

    What actively managed ETFs could add to a diversified portfolio

    November 21, 2026
    Most Popular

    🔥Juve target Chukwuemeka, Inter raise funds, Elmas bid in play 🤑

    August 20, 2025

    💵 Libra responds after Flamengo takes legal action and ‘freezes’ funds

    September 26, 2025

    🇮🇸 CPP Investments and Equinix complete atNorth acquisition to support growth of leading Nordic data center platform

    September 1, 2026
    © 2026 Fund Focus News
    • Get In Touch
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.