Foreign investors recorded net selling of nearly 214 trillion won (approximately $160.9 billion) in South Korea’s stock market this year, and roughly half of that was traced to UK-based accounts, according to data compiled by the South Korean financial regulator. Market watchers are focusing on the possibility that selling was concentrated as hedge fund money routed through UK accounts reduced leveraged positions.
According to the Financial Supervisory Service’s “September Foreign Securities Investment Trends” report released on the 30th of last month, foreign investors sold a net 213.999 trillion won (approximately $160.9 billion) of South Korean listed stocks in January-September. UK-based investors accounted for 97.488 trillion won (approximately $73.3 billion, 45.6%) and US-based investors for 65.177 trillion won (approximately $49.0 billion, 30.5%), with the two countries together making up 76.0% of the total.
UK-based investors were net sellers in every month except February through May. In particular, they dumped 69.332 trillion won (approximately $52.1 billion) over the three months from June to August, and kept selling even in August, when foreign investors as a whole turned net buyers. US-based investors, by contrast, sold more than 52 trillion won (approximately $39.1 billion) in May-June but bought a net 16.9 trillion won (approximately $12.7 billion) in July-August, showing an opposite trend.
| Category | Jan-Sep net selling | Share |
|---|---|---|
| UK-based | 97.488 trillion won | 45.6% |
| US-based | 65.177 trillion won | 30.5% |
| All foreign investors | 213.999 trillion won | 100% |
Lee Hyo-seob, head of the financial industry division at the Korea Capital Market Institute, said, “Past analyses show that UK-based investors have larger hedge funds and a somewhat stronger short-term investment tendency than US-based investors,” while adding, “Because a lot of European pension fund money is also executed through the UK, there is likely a mix of long-only funds and hedge funds.” Of US-based investors, he said, “They are centered on large long-only funds like BlackRock, so the money is more likely passive than active.” Indeed, the US-based share of holdings in South Korean stocks expanded from 41.2% at the end of last year to 43.9% at the end of September this year, while the UK-based share shrank from 10.9% to 7.5%.
There is also a structural backdrop that makes it difficult to interpret the UK-based selling solely as an exit by investors based in the UK itself. The Financial Supervisory Service’s statistics are compiled based on the location of settlement accounts, not the actual nationality of the investor. When a third-country hedge fund trades South Korean stocks through a prime brokerage (PBS) incorporated in the UK, that volume is also classified as UK-based.
Daishin Securities compared International Monetary Fund statistics with Financial Supervisory Service data and found that Korean stock holdings reported by UK residents stood at about 76.4 trillion won (approximately $57.4 billion) at the end of last year, only 0.53 times the 144.1 trillion won (approximately $108.4 billion) in UK-account holdings tallied by the Financial Supervisory Service. That means roughly half of UK-account holdings could be non-resident money. Relative to holdings, the scale of fund movement was also 3.8 times larger for UK-based accounts than for US-based accounts. Kwon Soon-ho, a researcher at Daishin Securities, analyzed, “Accounts where the money flowing in and out is large relative to holdings appear to have a greater share of short-term trading money than long-term holdings.”
The selling was extremely concentrated in the semiconductor sector. Daishin Securities analyzed the 10 trading days with the largest foreign net selling between June 22 and November 6 of this year and found that stocks other than semiconductors accounted for only 1.3% of total net selling. That contrasts sharply with the fact that non-semiconductor stocks made up 46% of market capitalization during the same period. Kwon estimated, “Because hedge funds’ South Korea positions were concentrated in large-cap semiconductor stocks, position reduction led to semiconductor selling.” The explanation is that hedge funds using derivatives such as total return swaps (TRS) have no choice but to mechanically cut their positions across the board when market volatility rises and margin burdens increase.
The rapid growth of leveraged exchange-traded funds (ETFs) is also cited as a factor that amplified intraday volatility. Net assets of leveraged and inverse ETFs based on South Korean stocks swelled from 9.95 trillion won (approximately $7.5 billion) at the end of last year to 41.3 trillion won (approximately $31.1 billion) on June 22 this year. The rebalancing volume ETFs carry out near the market close to match their target multiples reached 7.8% of KOSPI and KOSDAQ trading value in July. Kwon analyzed that the liquidation of short-term leveraged positions and mechanical ETF trading amplified volatility, and that the elevated volatility likely led conservative long-term investors such as pension funds to reduce their South Korea weighting.
Still, some argue that it is difficult to view all foreign selling as an exit of speculative money. From the perspective of global asset allocation funds, the KOSPI and large-cap semiconductor stocks have risen steeply since the start of the year, pushing the South Korea weighting in their portfolios well above target, and the large volume of selling came as they locked in profits and trimmed the overweight position, the interpretation goes. Lee said, “Long-term investment money can also be assumed to have sold to adjust its weighting, given how much South Korean stocks have risen,” adding, “It is closer to profit-taking than a bet on the short side.”
The problem is that it could take considerable time before foreign money that has finished taking profits returns to South Korea’s stock market. Because the won-dollar exchange rate has fallen from the 1,500-won level to the recent 1,330-won level, raising the value of the won, the price burden of South Korean stocks has grown for foreign investors holding dollars. On top of that, US Treasury yields have risen steeply, tightening global liquidity, and concerns that the earnings momentum of exporters could slow are also holding back buying. Lee said, “Foreign investors will return only when corporate earnings improve and liquidity loosens, but right now liquidity conditions are unfavorable, with interest rates rising steeply,” adding, “Normally in December, foreign asset managers enter book closing, so a large inflow of new money is hard to expect.”
