Legal & General (LSE: LGEN) shares have a patchy reputation. Terrific for income, terrible for growth. Is that fair?
Where growth’s concerned, I’m afraid it is. The FTSE 100 insurer and asset manager has trailed its obvious rival Aviva over the past five years, and by a wide margin.
The Legal & General share price climbed just 11.3% over that period, while Aviva’s surged 109%. That’s an astonishing performance gap. Anyone who picked Legal & General over Aviva will be kicking themselves. I know from bitter experience, because that’s what I did.
I was drawn by Legal & General’s higher yield, which has touched 10% at times. The income offers some consolation, but it doesn’t make up for all that lost growth.
The price of underperformance
Over five years, L&G’s has turned £10,000 into £13,660, with every dividend reinvested. By contrast, Aviva would have transformed the same £10,000 into around £25,400.
That’s a painful comparison. But before we get too depressed, things are picking up.
Aviva shares have risen 16% over the past year, but Legal & General jumped 25%. Its trailing yield’s a generous 7.5%, against Aviva’s 5.4%. So Legal & General’s delivered a total return of 32.5%, against Aviva’s 21.4%.
More reasons to be cheerful
L&G’s benefiting from growing demand for pension buyouts, as companies look to transfer the responsibility for paying defined benefit pensions to insurers. It also has new opportunities in workplace pensions, retirement products and private markets.
Its trading update (16 November) showed workplace net flows jumped 57% year on year to £8bn over the first nine months, while protection sales rose 21% to £248m. Assets under management climbed 4% to £1.23trn.
In 2025, core operating earnings per share (EPS) climbed 9%. For 2026, the board expects EPS to exceed the top end of its 6% to 9% target range. That’s good, but it’s hardly boomtime.
Still a lot to prove
There are risks. Pension buyout competition’s increasing, potentially squeezing margins. Its asset management division has suffered persistent net outflows, with £28bn leaving in the first nine months of 2026. If we get a stock market crash, there’ll be more.
I hoped Legal & General might prove itself a safe haven from US tech stock worries. Sadly not. Its shares have also fallen almost 7% in the past week. The outlook’s pretty underwhelming too. Today, the shares trade at 292p. Consensus forecasts produce a 12-month target price of 269p. If correct, that’s a drop of 7.7%.
I’m still holding onto Legal & General and believe the income’s relatively secure. But the company has a battle on its hands to boost profits and stock performance. It’s worth considering for income-focused investors, but anyone wanting growth on top might want to look elsewhere.
