Collecting Social Security early cost him $5,000 a year: ‘It was bleak.’ The pros and cons of claiming before your time
troyanpx/Envato
It’s a question that many Americans agonize over: When’s the best time to start collecting your Social Security benefits?
Experts have long advised waiting as long as possible, while some internet “finfluencers” claim that you should start as soon as you can.
Must Read
But starting your benefits early — before your Full Retirement Age (FRA) — means a permanent reduction in how much you’ll receive.
Some workers, though, will find they have no other option. For one Delaware man, an unforeseen circumstance left him having to choose between starting early, or weathering a “bleak” period of holding out for his FRA.
Plans can change
Alan Turner, of New Castle, Delaware, told the New York Times that in 2022, he lost his job designing museum exhibits, leaving him in a financial jam he wasn’t expecting.
“I haphazardly looked for work, but my prospects weren’t very good,” he told the Times.
He said that he had hoped he would be able to hold out until his FRA, which is 66 and a half. Unemployment benefits and his savings carried him for a while. “It was doable, but it was bleak,” Turner told the Times.
Turner chose to start collecting at age 64, a decision that meant collecting about $5,000 less a year than if he’d waited, the Times reported.
Should you wait?
You can start collecting Social Security benefits as early as age 62, but for anyone born after 1960, the FRA is 67.
For someone with an FRA of 67, starting benefits at 62 could mean a reduction of 30% in your benefit amount, compared to if you’d waited until your FRA.
For each year past your FRA that you delay starting benefits, up to age 70, your benefit amount will increase 8% a year.
Of course, starting benefits earlier does mean that you will potentially be collecting benefits for a longer period.
Some individuals make their decision on when to claim based on a so-called “break-even age,” an age at which you would have received more total benefit income than if you’d started collecting at age 62.
But many experts advise against relying on this framing.
“Another way of framing this discussion is to realize that claiming at any age before age 70 is a penalty,” Jason Fichtner, a former Social Security Administration executive, told CNBC.
The Social Security Administration advises that “when you think about retirement, be sure to plan for the long term.” That’s because, according to the SSA, about one in three individuals who are 65 today will live until they’re at least 90.
So experts often advise thinking of Social Security as “longevity insurance.”
You have other options, too
Working longer has other advantages as well. In addition to the obvious — continuing to work means you can continue building your retirement savings — it can also boost your benefits.
Benefits are calculated based on an average using your 35 highest-earning years. For individuals who don’t have 35 years on their earnings records, years without earnings are counted as zeroes. That means that “Years with no earnings reduce your retirement benefit amount,” the SSA says.
Even if you have 35 earnings years on your record, continuing to work can also mean a boost to benefits if you earn more than you did in any of your lowest-earning years.
For anyone who reaches their FRA and starts their benefits, then has second thoughts about not waiting until 70 to start claiming, there’s good news. You can suspend your benefits, and earn “delayed retirement credits for each month your benefits are suspended which will result in a higher benefit payment to you,” the SSA says.
Whatever decision you make when it comes to starting Social Security benefits, be sure you review all the options.
For some, like Alan Turner, life ends up making the decision for you. Ultimately, the best decision is one based on your own personal situation, and what makes sense for you.
What To Read Next
Join 250,000+ readers and get Moneywise’s best stories and exclusive interviews first — clear insights curated and delivered weekly. Subscribe now.